Boo! Your Hiring Process Is Scary (and Candidates Are Running)
Recruiting and PEO Expert
October 20, 2026
It’s October, which means pumpkin spice everything, questionable fun-size candy, and a hiring market that is genuinely spooky.
Not spooky because of the economy (though September’s jobs report was a bit of a jump scare, with employers adding just 29,000 jobs). Spooky because of what’s lurking in your applicant tracking system. resumehog
We’re talking about ghosting. And its creepy cousin, the ghost job.
The Call Is Coming From Inside the HR Department
Let’s start with a confession booth moment. According to a recent Resume Genius report, 86% of employers have ghosted a candidate because they had too many applicants to respond to, up from 79% in 2024. recruitingnewsnetwork
That means the vast majority of us have, at some point, let a perfectly nice human apply, interview, and then vanish into the mist.
And it gets better. Or worse. Hiring managers also admit to posting jobs they have no immediate plans to fill. Reasons include building a pool of candidates for future openings (47%). Meanwhile, 64% of hiring managers say they’ve misrepresented some aspect of a role during the hiring process. recruitingnewsnetworkinsurancebusinessmag
So to recap: the job might not exist, the description might be a creative interpretation, and nobody’s calling you back. It’s not a hiring process. It’s a haunted house with a careers page.
Why This Matters (Besides the Obvious “Don’t Be a Ghost”)
Here’s the part that should make your CFO’s blood run cold. Candidates remember. Research on ghost postings suggests that candidates who experience one become more skeptical of that employer’s future postings, which reduces applications even on genuinely open roles. And that skepticism travels through reviews and word of mouth. glider
Meanwhile, the market is not as dead as the jump scare suggests. ManpowerGroup’s Q4 survey found that 43% of employers plan to increase staffing between October and December, compared with 14% anticipating reductions. People are hiring. staffingindustry
So the companies that respond, communicate, and post honest roles have a real edge. As one industry voice put it, those that move top talent through the process more quickly will “own the market.” hrdive
How to Fix Your Hiring Process
1. Close the posting when the role is filled (or fake). A job that’s no longer real should come down faster than a Halloween decoration on November 1st.
2. Send the “no” email. Even a short, kind rejection beats silence. Closure is a gift, and it costs you roughly 30 seconds and zero candy. Auto response can help you with that.
3. Write job descriptions like you’d want to read them. Real title, real responsibilities, real pay range. Surprises are for trick-or-treating, not Day One.
4. Set expectations on timing. “You’ll hear from us by Friday” is a magical sentence. Just don’t say it unless you mean it.
5. Get the back end right. Nothing kills a great hire’s excitement like a clunky offer, a payroll hiccup, or a benefits enrollment maze. That’s where a good PEO earns its keep. We handle onboarding, payroll, benefits, and compliance so your new hire’s first week feels welcoming instead of like navigating blind curves in a corn maze.
6. Call in backup for the big roles. If you’re hiring an executive, a mediocre process doesn’t just cost you a candidate, it costs you a leader. Great executives are rarely scrolling job boards. They’re being approached, thoughtfully, by people who know how to start a conversation. That’s what executive search is for.
The Treat at the End
Hiring doesn’t have to be scary. Communicate, be honest, move with intention, and your reputation will do half the recruiting for you.
And if you’d rather leave the ghost-busting to the professionals, Infused can help, from finding your next executive to making sure that executive’s first paycheck, benefits, and paperwork go off without a single boo.
Ready to make your hiring process a lot less troubling? Contact us TODAY! 619 244 3000
Comments